Disaster Recovery Initiative
U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD)
[Docket No. FR-5051-N-01]
Federal Register / Volume 71, Number 29
Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 2006
Division of Administration
Action Plan Amendment for Disaster Recovery Funds
Kathleen Babineaux Blanco
Governor
Mitch Landrieu
Lieutenant Governor
Jerry Luke LeBlanc
Commissioner of Administration
Dr. Norman Francis
Chairman, LRA Board
Office of Community Development
1201 North Third Street, Suite 7-270
P.O. Box 94095
Baton Rouge, LA 70804-9095
http://www.LouisianaRebuilds.info
http://www.doa.louisiana.gov/cdbg/cdbg.htm
1
TABLE OF CONTENTS
2. Assistance to Homeowners................................................................. 5
3. Workforce and Affordable Rental Housing Programs ....................... 17
4. Homeless Housing Programs ........................................................... 25
5. Developer Incentives......................................................................... 26
6. Administration ................................................................................... 29
7. Planning ............................................................................................ 30
8. Technical Assistance ........................................................................ 30
9. Other Requirements.......................................................................... 30
10. Appendix 1 ...................................................................................... 38
11. Appendix 2 ...................................................................................... 40
12. Appendix 3 ...................................................................................... 42
2
1. Introduction
Hurricane Katrina hit the State of Louisiana on August 29, 2005, and Rita slammed into
the state on September 24, 2005. They were the second and third Category 5
hurricanes of the 2005 hurricane season. The storms were deadly and costly to
communities throughout the Gulf and particularly destructive to Louisiana. More than
1,100 persons lost their lives in Louisiana; approximately 18,000 businesses were
destroyed; roads, schools, public facilities, medical services were washed away; and
thousands of people were forced to relocate.
In the wake of the storms an unprecedented number of homes were destroyed or
severely damaged.
?? 123,000 homes were destroyed or suffered major damage.
?? 82,000 rental properties were destroyed or suffered major damaged.
?? Housing repair costs are estimated at $32 billion. Some, but not all, of this was
insured.
?? Of the rental and owner occupied units that are now uninhabitable, a substantial
portion were occupied by low income households.
HR 2863 provided $11.5 billion to the states of Mississippi, Louisiana, Alabama, Florida
and Texas through the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development's
Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Program. Louisiana received $6.2 billion
of those funds. President Bush has asked Congress for an additional $4.2 billion in
CDBG for Louisiana, which is pending appropriation, to fund the housing programs
described in this Action Plan amendment.
As the target of investment of this supplemental CDBG assistance, Governor Kathleen
Babineaux Blanco has prioritized housing redevelopment, infrastructure rehabilitation,
and economic development. The CDBG funds are available to the State subject to HUD
approval of action plans which describe how the funds will be used. The Louisiana
Recovery Authority (LRA) has been charged by the Governor and Louisiana Legislature
with statutory responsibility for developing policy and action plans for the CDBG funds.
The Louisiana Office of Community Development, the agency that runs the State's
annual CDBG Program, will administer the supplemental CDBG recovery program.
To promote sound short- and long-term recovery planning at the state and local levels
that impact land use decisions that reflect the need for responsible flood plain
management and growth, the State, through the LRA, is leading community planning
efforts in its most affected parishes. Dubbed "Louisiana Speaks", this effort is a
multifaceted planning process to develop a sustainable, long-term vision for South
Louisiana in the wake of the destruction caused by Hurricanes Katrina and Rita. The
plans developed locally through Louisiana Speaks will be supported by CDBG
allocations. The redevelopment of the housing stock funded partially by CDBG as
described herein will follow the plans derived through Louisiana Speaks and other local
efforts.
3
This Action Plan amendment describes The Road Home Housing Programs, consisting
of four sets of programs for the restoration of Louisiana's housing stock and its
communities: Homeowner Assistance Program, Workforce and Affordable Rental
Housing Programs, Homeless Housing Programs, and Developer Incentives. Future
Action Plan amendments will describe other aspects of the State's CDBG recovery
program.
1.1 Goals of The Road Home Housing Programs
The Road Home Housing Programs have several goals. They will:
?? Repair and rebuild quality housing in neighborhoods that are safe to live in;
?? Restore pre-storm value to homeowners who want to return;
?? Provide affordable rental housing opportunities for displaced residents; and
?? Provide housing for the return of critical workforce.
The Road Home Housing Programs will achieve their goals by ensuring, among other
things, that:
?? Neighborhoods are rebuilt pursuant to locally driven plans that emphasize safety
and reduce risks in rebuilding;
?? Homes are rebuilt in ways that ensure safer and smarter construction and meet
the State's codes and the latest available FEMA advisory base flood elevations1;
?? Neighborhoods are rebuilt in a manner that promotes mixed income
communities; and
?? Households with special needs such as the elderly and those with disabilities are
provided housing opportunities;
1.2 Basis for Recommendations
The Road Home Housing Programs are based on the best available information on
housing needs, housing costs, potential public funding and the ability of the programs to
leverage private resources. Funding for The Road Home Housing Programs come from
the supplemental appropriation of Community Development Block Grant Program funds
and Stafford Act Hazard Mitigation Grant Program Funds.
This Action Plan amendment describes funding for The Road Home programs in two
phases: partially funded and fully funded.
The need for assistance among homeowners far exceeds the initial allotment of CDBG
funds made in HR 2863. To meet that need and fully fund The Road Home, Louisiana
has worked with the Bush Administration to request from Congress an additional $4.2
billion in CDBG resources. In this Action Plan amendment, the program allocations
1 FEMA Advisory Based Flood Elevations are the first step in developing new required flood elevations for the
National Flood Insurance Program. Wherever this document refers to advisory base flood elevations, we mean the
most up-to-date flood elevations regulations or guidance from FEMA and the National Flood Insurance Program.
4
entitled "fully funded" amount to proposed levels of funding in anticipation of the
appropriation of an additional $4.2 billion for housing needs.
Partial funding levels are based on CDBG funds currently available to Louisiana. The
plan specifically details the allocation of $4.6 billion of the initial $6.2 billion of
supplemental CDBG funds to The Road Home.
Subject to further refinement of the program guidelines and structure of operations,
following are preliminary estimates of housing program costs:
The Road Home Program Budgets2
Partially
Funded
Fully Funded
Assistance to owner-occupants $3,551,600,000 $6,347,400,000
Homeless supports and housing $25,900,000 $25,900,000
Workforce and affordable rental
housing
$892,700,000 $1,535,700,000
Developer incentives and code
enforcement
$32,100,000 $32,100,000
State administrative costs $79,700,000 $120,900,000
Housing costs in Action Plan #1 $18,000,000 $18,000,000
TOTAL $4,600,000,000 $8,080,000,000
The Road Home will be fully funded with a total of $8.08 billion of CDBG funds based
upon damage and demand estimates grounded in the most current FEMA and HUD
damage data. Louisiana's damages exceed that of other states impacted by the
hurricanes of 2005 by three to four times, in nearly every category of damages.
Working with the Federal Coordinator of the Office of Gulf Coast Rebuilding, the LRA
has demonstrated that the cost of recovery based on the damages to owner-occupied
properties, rental properties, and other critical infrastructure such as hospitals, schools,
un-funded state and local infrastructure repairs, and sewer and water infrastructure will
require no less than $12.1 billion. The current supplemental CDBG funding of $6.21
billion, combined with anticipated Hazard Mitigation Grant Program funds available
through the Stafford Act, fall short of this total need by $4.2 billion. Without this
additional CDBG funding, the State of Louisiana cannot fully fund its housing program
for homeowners and renters, to meet the scale of the challenge. President Bush's
commitment to this funding was made in recognition of this need.
The CDBG funds directed to workforce and affordable rental housing will supplement an
estimated $1.7 billion in private equity investments derived from Low Income Housing
Tax Credits allotted to Louisiana through the federal Gulf Opportunity Zone legislation.
In addition, the State will supplement assistance to owner-occupants with an estimated
$1.17 billion in housing-related Hazard Mitigation Grant Program funds.
2 Budgets are exclusive of FEMA Hazard Mitigation Grant Program funds that may be spent on housing.
5
The damage from Hurricanes Katrina and Rita disproportionately impacted families with
low to moderate incomes. HUD therefore requires that at least fifty percent of the
supplemental CDBG dollars allocated to Louisiana for recovery be invested in programs
that directly support those families. Accordingly, in both the partially and fully funded
housing programs described herein, the great majority of funds will go to low- and
moderate-income families.
If federal agencies require changes to the State's proposed Action Plan amendment or
program costs exceed projections and available funding, Louisiana will be required to
modify this proposed Action Plan amendment.
2. Assistance to Homeowners3
2.1 Overview of the Homeowner Assistance Program
In the aftermath of Hurricanes Katrina and Rita, an estimated 123,000 owner-occupied
homes were destroyed or suffered major damage, according to FEMA. In response to
this unprecedented disaster, Louisiana will use $3,551,600,000 of current supplemental
CDBG funds and approximately $1.17 billion of Hazard Mitigation funds to help selected
owner-occupants repair or rebuild their homes, buy or build replacement homes, or sell
unwanted properties so they can be redeveloped or converted to open space. In order
to avoid future flood losses, all reconstruction work will meet or exceed the latest
available FEMA advisory base flood elevations and meet the legal requirements under
the State Uniform Construction Code.
Note that the State will require an additional $4.2 billion of CGBG in order to provide the
full proposed assistance to all of the Louisiana homeowners who suffered major or
severe damage. President Bush has requested those additional funds from Congress.
The budget for owner-occupant assistance following that additional appropriation is
anticipated to be $6,347,400,000 in CDBG funds, with additional funds from the State's
Hazard Mitigation Grant Program
The overarching purpose of The Road Home is to rebuild Louisiana's impacted
communities. Devastated communities will be blighted by abandoned homes, clouded
land titles, and disinvestments if a large portion of the financial assistance is not directly
invested in rebuilding homes or buying replacement homes in the affected areas.
Therefore, the most comprehensive financial and technical assistance packages will be
made available to those pre-Katrina and Rita homeowners who make the effort and take
the risks to move back to play a part in rebuilding Louisiana.
3 For the purpose of this Action Plan amendment homeowner and owner occupant are used interchangeably.
6
Financial incentives and advisory services will be available for homeowners who wish
to:
?? Repair - incentives to promote rehabilitation
?? Rebuild - financial incentives to reconstruct on the same site if repair is infeasible
or not economically viable;
?? Buyout/Relocate - purchase of the home by the program in exchange for an
agreement to resettle in Louisiana; or
?? Sell - voluntary sale of the home with no requirements to resettle or otherwise
remain in the community.
2.2 Eligibility for Homeowner Assistance
To be eligible for the Homeowner Assistance Program:
?? The owner must be able to prove that he or she owned and occupied the
property as a primary residence at the time of the Katrina/Rita disasters, prior to
August 29, 2005;
?? The home must in be a single-unit or double-unit structure4; and
?? The owner must have registered for FEMA Individual Assistance and the home
must be categorized by FEMA as having been "destroyed" or having suffered
"major" damage. Homeowners who were approved by FEMA for $5,200 or more
in FEMA home repair assistance (a component of the Individual Assistance
Program) will fall into one of these categories. In certain cases, FEMA may fail to
notify a homeowner that the home has been classified as destroyed or suffering
major damage, or FEMA has declared a home with such damage ineligible for its
home repair assistance program because the home was covered by insurance.
These homeowners will still be eligible for assistance, though damage severity
that meets the FEMA damage classification at the destroyed and major damage
levels will be verified through alternative means.
Applicants must meet all of the above requirements to receive assistance. Homeowners
that believe they have suffered major or severe damage, but did not qualify for FEMA
assistance will be able to appeal their eligibility for The Road Home. Homeowners who
believe they will be eligible for the program are currently encouraged to register with
The Road Home registry at www.LouisianaRebuilds.info or by calling 1-888-ROAD-2-
LA.
During the process of reviewing applications to The Road Home, the LRA shall make
available information about the repair, rebuilding and relocation preferences of
applicants in order to inform local planning processes. In areas where a high proportion
4 If the Homeowner Assistance Program is chosen, the full double-unit structure will serve as the basis for
calculation of assistance up to the program cap of $150,000. For all other owner-occupied multi-unit
structures, if the homeowner chooses the Homeowner Assistance Program, funding of up to $150,000 is
available, but is based only on the damages to and value of the unit in which the owner resides. The
owner occupant landlord may also choose the Small Rental Property Repair Program instead.
7
of homeowners are choosing not to invest, state or local authorities may limit access
only to Buyout/Relocate and Sell programs.
2.3 Requirements for Receiving Homeowner Assistance
To accomplish the State's goal to resurrect damaged communities, the LRA proposes to
encourage homeowners' investment of federal recovery funds in Louisiana. To that end,
homeowners that make the decision to reinvest in Louisiana will be eligible for the most
generous levels of assistance. They will be required to demonstrate that commitment to
the State by signing a legally binding covenant described below.
In exchange for financial incentives, homeowners must:
?? Be willing to sign a release so that information given to FEMA can be verified by
the Program;
?? Independently from FEMA, agree to verification of their ownership status and the
amount of disaster-related damage to the home;
?? Swear to the accuracy and completeness of all information provided to the
Program under penalty of law;
?? Agree in legally binding documents to follow through on certain actions related to
a home in exchange for compensation, including but not limited to the following:
o Ensure that the home they occupy meets the legal requirements under
the State Uniform Construction Code,5 complies with local zoning, and
complies with the latest available FEMA guidance for base flood
elevations unless exceptions are granted by the LRA based on
reasonable alternatives where safety is not minimzed;6
o Assure the home will remain owner-occupied for at least three years
after the completion of repairs/replacement or new home purchase;
o Maintain residential hazard insurance;
o Maintain flood insurance if the home was previously flooded or is
located in a flood zone;
o Agree to subrogate claims for unpaid and outstanding insurance claims
back to the Program;
o If relocating, move to another home in Louisiana;
o Ensure mitigation efforts are undertaken, if mitigation can be done to
make a home safer and are cost beneficial to undertake, and if the
homeowner's eligible assistance allows funds for such purposes; and
o If selling the property to the State and the home has no historic value or
is not salvageable, convey the property as a cleared site, agree in
5 A number of communities have not yet adopted or implemented the State Uniform Construction Code. Pursuant to the State's
commitment to rebuild safer and stronger communities, homeowner assistance provided by The Road Home will be contingent
upon local enforcement of and individual compliance with all legal requirements under the code.
6 Federal and state law may require homes in historic districts to meet additional standards.
8
writing to allow the Army Corps of Engineers or another governmental
entity to clear the property, or provide funds from the sale proceeds for
demolition and clearance by the acquiring entity.
The above terms and conditions apply to the home that is repaired, rebuilt or purchased
using program funds. Homeowners that fail to meet all of these terms and conditions
will forfeit the property that is repaired, rebuilt or purchased using program funds and/or
be required to repay the financial assistance provided through this program.
2.4 Amounts and Forms of Homeowner Assistance
2.4.1 Maximum Assistance
The maximum financial assistance from all program resources for owner occupants is
up to $150,000. The proposed ceiling assumes that:
?? All federal funds currently allocated to and sought for the program will be
available, including the additional $4.2 billion that will fully fund The Road Home;
and
?? Estimates of likely demand for assistance derived from HUD, FEMA and SBA
data are accurate.
The partial funding levels for programs contained herein are based on the current
supplemental CDBG appropriation. If sufficient funds are ultimately unavailable to fully
fund the proposed program or demand exceeds estimates, the maximum amount of
financial assistance per household must be lowered. Because Congress has not yet
fully funded The Road Home, this Action Plan amendment proposes to provide an initial
installment of assistance to homeowners toward their full assistance of up to $150,000.
To provide this installment, a homeowner's eligible assistance will be calculated under
the fully funded program design and then allocated as half of that amount.
It is the intent of the program to provide a homeowner the resources to get into a home,
based upon the homeowner's financial means, needs, and the pre-storm value of the
damaged home. Not every homeowner is necessarily entitled to the maximum amount
of financial assistance, however, and in many cases The Road Home will not provide
100% of the required resources for repair, rebuilding or resettlement. This is true for
many reasons, such as the fact that assistance is capped, and that assistance will be
reduced by any insurance payments for damage to the structure of the home, by any
FEMA assistance for home repairs or replacement, and by other compensation for the
loss.
2.4.2 Financial Incentives to Repair/Rebuild
The program will provide financial incentives for homeowners that repair or rebuild their
homes on the same site. Homeowners will receive varying amounts of assistance
depending on the condition of their home and the compensation received from other
sources.
9
Homeowners remaining in Louisiana will be eligible for assistance in three tiers: an
incentive grant to cover uninsured, uncompensated losses to the home and restore prestorm
value; a hazard mitigation grant, whenever the home can be repaired or rebuilt
with cost-effective mitigation measures; and, where a homeowner cannot secure
conventional financing, an affordable incentive loan, structured within the homeowner's
financial means, for any gap between the damaged home's pre-storm value and
allowed repair/rebuilding costs.
Pursuant to federal statute and HUD requirements for the CDBG program, homeowner
assistance may not duplicate any benefits, derived from any source, that are received
by the homeowner as a result of damages incurred during Hurricanes Katrina and Rita.
Thus the State must not duplicate insurance of any type, FEMA, or other payments
received by the homeowner for structural repairs required for such damages.
An explanation of the calculation of financial assistance under the fully funded
Homeowner Asssistance Program follows below. Appendix 2 provides two examples of
how hypothetical households might be assisted to repair or rebuild their home.
Homeowners will first calculate their personal Eligible Assistance Amount using the
following formula.
Eligible assistance does not represent an entitlement to the homeowner, under any
circumstances.
The Eligible Assistance Amount will generally be paid in three tiers.
?? The first tier will be an Incentive Grant that is intended to restore the pre-storm
value of the property. The Incentive Grant will be made under the conditions
attached to the legal instrument described in Section 2.3. The amount is
calculated as follows:
Incentive Grant = Lesser of
Eligible Assistance Amount
Eligible Assistance Amount to Repair/Rebuild equals
Lesser of:
• Pre-storm value of the home (times) Percent damage to
the home (plus) Eligible Mitigation costs (plus) Gap to
meet allowed repair/rebuilding costs
(minus) Insurance (minus) FEMA Repair Payment
(minus) any Other financial assistance for repair
OR
• $150,000
10
OR
Pre-Storm Value x Loss Percentage (minus) Insurance, FEMA Repair Payments and
Other Financial Assistance for Repair
The State will enlist inspectors, through the private contractor administering the
program, to determine the appropriate level of damages to the home. It is the
State's policy that participants in the Homeowner Assistance Program deserve a
fair and independent estimate of projection of damages from the storm,
regardless of cause of damage. The program also reserves the right to use
damage estimates catalogued by FEMA and insurance companies where those
estimates are deemed reliable.
To accurately calculate homeowner's loss, the program must base assistance on
a fair and equitable pre-storm valuation of the home. There are several sources
of valuation available, each of which has benefits and drawbacks, including fair
market values determined through Automated Valuation Methods (AVM) and
other alternative methods such as insured value, a recent pre-storm appraisal, or
assessed value for property tax purposes. The Louisiana Recovery Authority
and Office of Community Development will determine the final method for
calculation of pre-storm value in conjunction with the private professional
services firm responsible for administering homeowner assistance, when full
consideration can be given to the capacity and expertise of the firm and any
subcontractors brought on to perform valuations.
While the program must apply a common method for valuation to all homes
qualifying for assistance to efficiently address all applications, there will be cases
in which the homeowner believes the standard assessment does not accurately
reflect the pre-storm value, due to unaccounted structural improvements or other
factors. In such cases, homeowners will be able to appeal the valuation by
presenting a valid alternative assessment or other evidence. The process and
requirements for appeal will be determined in conjunction with the private
administrator.
Note that The Road Home is not an entitlement program and cannot go over
budget. If costs exceed budgeted projections, grant assistance to homeowners
will have to be reduced, and the program would pro-rate benefits to all
homeowners.
Finally, for homeowners who did not carry the type of insurance required for the
home (for example, those who were living in a flood plain but did not have flood
insurance), the Incentive Grant will be reduced by 30%.
?? The second tier will consist of mitigation assistance, with funding from either the
Hazard Mitigation Grant Program, provided through the federal Stafford Act, or
CDBG. These funds will complement CDBG assistance for homes that are in
11
flood plains or otherwise eligible for FEMA-funded hazard mitigation assistance.
The amount of the hazard mitigation grant will be calculated as follows:
Mitigation Grant = Eligible Mitigation Costs
OR
Eligible Assistance Amount - Incentive Grant
?? If additional funds are required to help the homeowner get into a home and
funding needs fall within the eligible assistance amount, the third tier will be an
Incentive Loan. When conventional financing options exceed homeowners'
financial means under HUD guidelines for the monthly amount a homeowner can
afford to pay for housing, and the homeowner demonstrates that they have
pursued conventional financing and have been denied, the Incentive Loan will be
offered to provide an affordable way for homeowners to return to a home when
the Incentive and Mitigation Grants do not meet repair or replacement costs. The
Incentive Loan will include an allocation for soft second mortgages repayable on
sale of the property. Additionally, it will leverage private capital to create larger
pools of affordable loan investment capital through the use of mechanisms such
as a loan loss guarantee pool and below market interest rates through rate
reduction buy-down features. For those cases where it is necessary to do so, the
amount of Incentive Loan will be calculated as follows:
Incentive Loan = Eligible Assistance Amount (minus) Incentive, Mitigation
Grants
As in the determination of pre-storm value, the procedures used to determine the
reasonable additional costs to repair or rebuild a home will be established in conjunction
with the capacity and expertise of the administering contractor.
The State may also offer additional incentives for homeowners who choose to repair or
rebuild within the same parish.
For instances in which the sum of remaining pre-storm loans and the Incentive Loan
exceed the market value of the home, the program will develop policies to mitigate the
impacts of "negative equity" positions on the home and homeowner by adjusting the
repayment terms.
In addition, the program shall give recognition and consideration during implementation
to homeowners who may have been in a position of negative replacement value prior to
the storms. This occurs when a homeowner's pre-storm value would not have
sufficiently covered their pre-storm rebuilding costs.
12
2.4.3 Buyout/Relocate
Homeowners choosing to move elsewhere in Louisiana will be able to sell their homes
to the State and receive assistance under the guidelines described for homeowners that
rebuild on the same site. Owners choosing this option must meet the same eligibility
requirements and agree to the same legally binding actions applicable to those
choosing to repair or rebuild. Those requirements are described in Sections 2.2 and 2.3
of this Action Plan amendment. For these buyouts to occur, a lien holder may be asked
to write off a portion of the current outstanding principal balances of the loan or other
lien, and to give consideration to potential lost equity of the homeowner.
Homeowners who help to shoulder the burden of community recovery by choosing to
rebuild within their parish will always be the highest priority of the program. The State
may also offer additional incentives for homeowners who choose a buyout but relocate
within the same parish.
2.4.4 Sale
Some owner-occupants may choose none of the basic options: to repair, rebuild or
relocate in Louisiana. In these instances, the State will compensate the homeowner for
60% of the home's pre-storm value, less insurance and FEMA repair funds. Sale
compensation will not exceed repair or rebuilding costs for the home. For these buyouts
to occur, a lien holder may be asked to write off a portion of the current outstanding
principal balances of the loan or other lien.
2.5 Redevelopment of Purchased Property
Properties purchased through The Road Home Homeowner Assistance program will be
either redeveloped to be returned to commerce or preserved as green space, in a
manner which is consistent with local land use plans and direction. Pursuant to a
primary goal of the Homeowner Assistance Program, purchased land will not be left to
blight and disrepair. The LRA recognizes two distinct options for assigning responsibility
for management of land assets. Land acquisition, maintenance and redevelopment can
be managed by a:
Compensation for Selling Home
With No Other Obligations equals
Lesser Of:
60% of Pre-storm value (minus) insurance (minus) FEMA repair
payments (minus) Other repair assistance
OR
Incentive Grant for which they would otherwise be eligible
13
1. State Agency - Assign these properties to a new or existing state agency which
will be charged with working in ways consistent with local land use plans and
direction, packaging the properties for redevelopment, offering them for
redevelopment through competitive bids, and overseeing the redevelopment of
the property consistent with local plans. Any proceeds derived through the sale
of the property that exceed approved expenses associated with the
redevelopment of the property would be returned to the Supplemental CDBG
program.
2. Local redevelopment authority - Transfer specific properties from the state to a
local redevelopment agency upon approval by the LRA of the authority's
redevelopment plan that takes into account local land use guidelines. The local
authority would package the properties, offer them up for redevelopment through
competitive bids, and oversee the redevelopment of the property. Any proceeds
derived through the sale of the property that exceed approved expenses
associated with the redevelopment of the property would be returned to the
Supplemental CDBG program.
For properties that are to become green space as a result of a decision by local
authorities, those properties will be transferred to the appropriate local land
management agency which will operate and maintain them.
The LRA has endorsed the findings and recommendations of the American Institute of
Architects and the American Planning Association planning conference held on behalf
of the LRA in November 2005. Consistent with those recommendations, for properties
that are acquired by the Homeowner Assistance Program or other land assembly
program for redevelopment, the State will insure that 25% of the properties are used for
affordable housing according to HUD guidelines for the HOME program.
Whether properties are managed by a state agency or local redevelopment authority,
the properties acquired by the Homeowner Assistance Program or other land assembly
programs must retain the affordability requirements defined by this program after their
transfer. The State should monitor the property to assure the requirements are met and
maintained.
The final assignment of redevelopment authority will be resolved during the month of
May by the State through ongoing deliberations with the Louisiana Congressional
delegation, state legislators, local authorities, and civic leaders.
Under either scenario, the LRA recognizes the potential for a significant return on
investment in property redevelopment, a scenario demonstrated with research in a
recent report of the Gerson Lehrman Group. The LRA is committed to reinvesting these
proceeds in the comprehensive community redevelopment activities already supported
by Supplemental CDBG funds allocated through state programs, including The Road
Home. The priorities of recycled funds shall include housing restoration, affordable
14
housing for homeowners and renters, infrastructure enhancements, and economic
development activities designed to help recreate strong communities which are closely
tied to transit, jobs, and public services.
2.6 Treatment of Homeowners with Special Circumstances
Assignability: Subsequent to the launch of The Road Home, the State will allow an
owner to sell his or her home on the open market and to assign rights to program
assistance to the new buyer. Assigned grants will require the new buyer to carry the
same three-year owner-occupancy requirement and other legally binding terms and
conditions that govern the repair and rebuild options. The new owner to whom
assistance benefits have been assigned will be eligible only for the repair/rebuild option.
Death or Infirmity of Eligible Owner: In the event that a homeowner has died since the
time of the storms, an heir must have been placed into legal possession of the property
to be eligible for homeowner assistance in place of the deceased owner. If a
homeowner is incapacitated due to illness or other infirmity, someone with a legal right
to bind that person legally, such as is provided by a power of attorney, is eligible to
apply for assistance on behalf of the homeowner.
If a homeowner who has received assistance from The Road Home dies after receiving
assistance and signing the required legally binding commitments, the owner-occupancy
requirement between the State and the homeowner will remain applicable to the
property repaired, rebuilt or acquired using program funds. If the homeowner received
a soft second loan as the Incentive Loan, a transfer of the property as a result of death
or infirmity will not trigger the repayment of the loan by the legal heir, unless some
portion of the succession transaction is a cash transaction for a share of the property.
Owner-Occupants Who Have Already Sold Their Principal Residence: Some
homeowners may have chosen to sell their homes prior to launch of the Homeowner
Assistance Program. It is the goal of The Road Home to ensure that damaged
properties qualifying under the Homeowner Assistance Program do not remain blighted
and undeveloped. If the development goals of the program are met for the damaged
property, a homeowner that can demonstrate that he or she remains in a loss situation
after selling the damaged property to another party may receive assistance under the
program to compensate for remaining losses.
Owners Who Have Started or Completed Repairs: Assistance will be provided to
owners who have already commenced or completed home repairs or the construction of
replacement homes, so long as all the requirements of the Program are met. Policies
will be set for discounting assistance amounts for any grants or below-market interest
rate loans from government agencies that may have been received by an owner from
for these purposes.
15
Owners Who Have Received Other Assistance: Policies will be set for discounting
compensation amounts for any grants or below-market interest rate loans from
government agencies that may have been received by an owner for these purposes.
Pursuant to federal statute, assistance from The Road Home must be used to repay any
loans from the Small Business Administration (SBA) that a homeowner has received for
the same losses.
Owners of Manufactured Housing: In order to qualify for homeowner assistance, the
owner of a manufactured home must also own the land on which the damaged home
was located.
Any homeowner may appeal the decision related to eligibility, damage assessments,
amount of assistance and grant offsets made by the program.
2.7 Accounts for Receipt of Funds
To help ensure that Program incentive grants, incentive loans, insurance payments and
FEMA household assistance payments provided to homeowners are invested in
housing, owners will be encouraged and assisted, and may be required, to open deposit
accounts in the owner's name. The Program will work with financial institutions to set up
standard terms for managing such accounts and payouts from them.
2.8 Homeowner Assistance Centers - Process for Receiving Assistance
Louisiana has initiated a Call Center to allow former homeowners to indicate their
interest in returning to their neighborhoods and investing in their homes. The Call
Center is the first step in what will be an aggressive campaign to solicit applications for
the Homeowner Assistance Programs.
To open lines of contact between displaced Louisiana residents and The Road Home,
citizens may now register key information about their damaged homes by calling 1-888-
ROAD-2-LA (888-762-3252; TTY 1-800-566-4224 ) to submit that data to the State's
registry, or logging on to a one-stop web portal - www.LouisianaRebuilds.info. This
registry pertains only to homes that were occupied by homeowners and damaged by
hurricanes Katrina or Rita.
When the program commences, eligible homeowners will be notified by mail, email
and/or telephone to the greatest extent possible of the opportunity to apply for
assistance. Information about financing programs and counseling services will be
posted on public websites as well as provided through other resources such as
Assistance Centers that will be established in various locations.
The Program will not publish application forms or detailed
descriptions of the process for receiving assistance until the
comment period has ended and the State of Louisiana has
determined the amount of federal funds that will be available for all
recovery programs.
16
In order to rebuild, most homeowners will have to navigate a maze of obstacles such as
negotiating insurance settlements, dealing with mortgage issues, understanding the
implications of new flood maps, and dealing with building contractors. Before the
amount of program financial compensation can be determined, an owner will have to
make decisions on whether to repair their home, replace it on-site, accept a buyout and
relocate in the parish or state, or sell. If an owner has been unable to return to the
community, he or she will likely need help finding temporary housing to live in while
managing this process. While some homeowners can overcome these barriers
themselves, many homeowners will need expert, trustworthy advisors, in addition to
receiving financial assistance.
To respond to these needs, Assistance Centers will be the "storefronts" where
homeowners can apply for assistance and gain access to advisory services. Rebuilding
Advisors will help homeowners accomplish the following:
• Provide information to help homeowners evaluate the four assistance options-
repair, replace, relocate or sell-and the amount of financial assistance allowed
for each;
• Provide information to owners on how to deal with mortgage issues, or refinance
if necessary;
• Provide information to assist owners in selecting professional services providers
such as home inspectors, architects, surveyors (for replacement homes) to
design and prepare for repairing or replacing homes;
• Provide information to assist owners in selecting repair contractors, homebuilders
and manufactured housing companies; and
• Provide information about fair housing rights and protections against housing
discrimination.
The Assistance Centers will help mitigate the potential for misunderstanding and abuse
by providing standardized, structured, and guided relationships between homeowners
and service providers. In addition, the Assistance Centers will maintain registries of
professional service providers and building contractors.
Through the Solicitation for Offer, Assistance Centers will be directed by the selected
management firm and staffed by contracted experts, which may include non-profit
organizations specializing in providing advisory services to homeowners. See Section 5
for more details.
17
Registrants calling The Road Home or logging onto www.LouisianaRebuilds.info will be
asked to provide important information, including the resident's name, current address
and the location of the affected home, phone numbers, mortgage information, the status
of any insurance settlements and any FEMA or U.S. Small Business Association (SBA)
applications or assistance.
3. Workforce and Affordable Rental Housing
Programs
Approximately 82,000 rental housing units received major or severe damage in
Hurricanes Katrina and Rita. Replacement of the damaged or destroyed rental housing
in the hurricane ravaged areas is vital to the return of a strong workforce, and is a
lynchpin of Louisiana's economic recovery. All sectors of the economy have reported a
workforce shortage due to a lack of affordable housing. Rental housing stock is also
imperative to support the return of the high proportion of residents that were renters
prior to the storms, particularly in New Orleans, as well as the return of homeowners
transitioning into repaired and rebuilt homes over the coming months.
For these reasons, several programs are proposed to support the redevelopment of
rental housing in the storm-impacted areas. To support the programs, the State has set
aside a total of $892,700,000 of currently available CDBG funds, and proposed to be
increased to $1,535,700,000 upon the appropriation of the additional CDBG funds
pending in Congress.
The Road Home Workforce and Affordable Rental Housing Programs have four broad
goals:
?? To ensure that the workforce needed to accommodate full economic recovery
has access to affordable rental housing;
?? To provide affordable rental housing to low income households who could not
otherwise afford to return to their communities;
?? To ensure that affordable rental housing is provided in the context of high-quality,
sustainable mixed-income communities; and
?? To ensure that a portion of affordable rental units will host supportive services for
families with special needs or high risks following their extended displacement.
To achieve these four goals, the programs described below prioritize deep affordability
of rental units and the balanced allocation of these deeply affordable units within mixedincome
communities. The program will create an estimated 36,000 to 51,000 units, in
a broad mixture of deeply affordable units, mixed income development, small rental
properties, and other tax credit projects.
Summary of Rental Units Built or Restored and Program
Dollars for Fully Funded Program
18
Program Number of Units CDBG Dollars
LIHTC/CDBG Piggyback
Market Rate Units
Below Market Rate
Very Low Income
18,000 - 33,000
5,000 - 15,000
13,000 - 18,000
6,000 - 9,000
$552,410,000
$0
$0
$552,410,000
Supportive Housing Services 0 units built; 3,000 served $72,730,000
Flexible Developer Incentives N/A $41,560,000
Small Rental Properties
Market Rate Units
Below Market Rate
18,000
~ 6,000
~ 12,000
$869,000,000
TOTAL 36,000 - 51,000 units $1,535,700,000
Deep affordability refers to units reserved for individuals with incomes as low as 20% of
the area median. Mixed-income communities will be prioritized when they are
developments with market rate rental units or single family homes in the same
development with a range of affordable and deeply affordable rental units, for renters
20% to 60% of the area median income.
Based on current estimates, the Workforce and Affordable Rental Housing Programs
and the Gulf Opportunity Zone's Low Income Housing Tax Credits may create between
25,000 and 30,000 units available for citizens at or below 60% of the area median
income for the next twenty years. The State expects that as many as half of those units
may rent at or below 50% of the area median income level for the next twenty years.
The LRA will allocate these funds for the Workforce and Affordable Rental Programs by
formula to ensure that those parishes with the most damaged or destroyed rental
housing have adequate resources to replace significant numbers of affordable rental
units. It is the strong recommendation of the LRA that the Low Income Housing Tax
Credits should also follow this geographic allocation formula and prioritization to meet
affordability and mixed-income development goals, such that all projects benefiting from
tax credit projects should be directed to include units of deeper affordability for very low
income families.
The State proposes these rental programs as a means to focus on the housing needs of
low to moderate income people in the most heavily damaged areas. According to the
National Low Income Housing Coalition Research Note #05-02:
"Forty-seven percent of the housing units in the entire Katrina affected area [of the Gulf
Coast] were rental units. In New Orleans, 55% were rental units. Fully 20% of the rental
units lost in New Orleans were affordable to extremely low income households, i.e.
households earning 30% of AMI or less, amounting to 16,000 units. This percentage
was 16%, 22,000 units, for all Katrina affected areas. Thus, 73% of all the rental units
affordable to extremely low income households in the Katrina affected areas were in
New Orleans and likely destroyed."
19
The table below summarizes the budget for all rental programs:
Budgets for Rental Housing Programs
Rental Program Partially Funded Fully Funded
LIHTC/CDBG Piggyback $311,690,000 $552,410,000
Supportive Housing $46,750,000 $72,730,000
Flexible Developer
Incentives
$41,560,000 $41,560,000
Small Rental Properties $492,700,000 $869,000,000
TOTAL $892,700,000 $1,535,700,000
3.1 Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) "Piggyback" Program
Through legislation creating the Gulf Opportunity Zone (GO Zone), Congress has
authorized a special allocation of Low Income Housing Tax Credits (LIHTC) that are
expected to generate an estimated $1.7 billion over three years in private investment in
the repair and new construction of affordable rental housing. The combination of LIHTC
incentives and CDBG funds that piggyback the tax credits will promote the twin goals of
dramatically increasing the supply of rental units affordable to a wide range of low- to
moderate-income families and expanding rental housing supply as a part of stable
mixed-income developments and neighborhoods.
When The Road Home is fully funded, the State proposes to combine the resources of
the LIHTC incentives, CDBG Piggyback funding, available HOME funds, Section 8
housing vouchers, and leveraged private investments to generate between 18,000 and
33,000 new or restored rental units, of which an estimated 5,000 to 15,000 units will be
rented at market rates and 13,000 to 18,000 will have below-market rents. In any single
unit, other federal subsidies shall not duplicate assistance to the same beneficiary.
To support the development of mixed income communities and to ensure the restoration
of rental housing in the most heavily impacted parishes, the LRA will work with the
Louisiana Housing Finance Agency, which administers the LIHTC Program, to assure
that all approved GO Zone LIHTC projects integrate multiple tiers of affordable rental
units and prioritize the integration of affordable units with market-rate rental units. The
intent of this program is to use the powerful financial incentives of the LIHTC program,
CDBG Piggyback funding and the flexible incentives program described in Section 4.3
to motivate developers to build new mixed-income communities that accommodate
families from across the income spectrum. If LIHTC applications without this deeper
tiering of affordable units are able to qualify for tax credits, then it will be hard for the
goals of this piggyback program to be met. Furthermore, to ensure the success of the
CDBG Piggyback Program, the LRA strongly urges the Louisiana Housing Finance
Agency to direct that GO Zone LIHTC benefits be similarly targeted to parishes which
suffered the most damaged or destroyed rental properties as described for the
Workforce and Affordable Rental Housing programs above.
20
Though units developed under the LIHTC must by law be affordable to households with
incomes as high as 60% of area median income, the extra investment incentives built
into the special GO Zone allocation of LIHTC mean that, by State estimates, rents for
LIHTC units in Louisiana can be made affordable to families with incomes between 45%
and 60% of area median income. The LRA will work with the Louisiana Housing
Finance Agency to develop future Qualified Allocation Plans (QAP) for LIHTC to give
preference to and fund projects that meet deeper affordability goals than the required
60% of area median income7, and that use the full capacity of the Piggyback Program.
Louisiana intends to accommodate families with incomes below 45% AMI, however. In
order for the LIHTC program to create a rental supply for such very low-income
households, additional subsidies are needed. The State will therefore make available
CDBG funds to provide incentives to investors so that, when the program is fully funded
by the anticipated $4.2 billion appropriation, an estimated 6,000 to 9,000 of the
estimated 13,000 to 18,000 affordable rental units produced under the LIHTC program
can be reserved for-and made affordable to-working families with incomes between
20% and 40% of AMI. It is the strong intention of the State to reserve all CDBG money
devoted to very affordable rental units for units that are built as a part of mixed-income
developments, with a priority given to those including market rate units.
Furthermore, under the current partially funded program, the State proposes that a
portion of the estimated 6,000 to 9,000 units targeted to very low-income families be
made available to households with special needs such as persons with disabilities,
families with disabled family members, and the elderly. The funding for such supportive
services is outlined in Section 4.2 of this document.
Project Eligibility and Estimated Budgets8
Developers will be eligible for supplemental CDBG funding for approved LIHTC rental
projects on which they agree to certain limitations on rents and occupant income for the
first twenty years of the project. When The Road Home is fully funded, CDBG piggyback
funds aimed at increasing the supply of units available to very low income households
for renters, with incomes between 20% and 40% of the area median, is estimated in the
table below.
Target
Household
Income
Target Number of
Units
Total Estimated CDBG
Funding
20% AMI 2,000-3,000 $263,460,000
30% AMI 2,000-3,000 $184,140,000
7 Area Median Income is defined annually by the federal Department of Housing and Urban Development for each metropolitan
area and non-metropolitan parish in the United States. FY2006 income estimates for Louisiana can be found at
http://www.huduser.org/Datasets/IL/IL06/la_fy2006.pdf.
8 Calculations used to determine the demand for CDBG funds based on assumed rents and income targets are available from
the LRA.
21
40% AMI 2,000-3,000 $104,810,000
50% AMI 3,500- 4,500 $0
60% AMI 3,500-4,500 $0
Above 60% AMI 5,000-15,000 $0
TOTAL 18,000-33,000 $552,410,000
Among the CDBG financing mechanisms being considered to make it feasible for
developers to provide the estimated 6,000 to 9,000 units that will be available to and
rented by very low income tenants are:
• Gap financing to reduce the costs of debt service, so that lower rents (and lower
cash flow) can be made feasible; and
• Funding of operating reserves for projects to enable rental property owners to
charge lower rents.
The project costs for affordable units and LIHTC projects are likely to vary greatly
because of the uncertainty of many cost factors and market conditions. The State will
prepare clear criteria by which projects will be ranked, such as quality of the
development and units, experience of the development firm, the per-unit subsidies
sought at varying levels of affordability between 20% and 60%, and the financial
strength of the firm. Proposals should be selected by the State based on the most
competitive proposals that maximize these identified criteria. Further, each application
should be scrutinized by underwriters in light of the criteria and proposed project costs.
The State should negotiate with applicants to seek the best possible outcomes for each
project.
Officers of the LRA, Louisiana Office of Community Development, and Louisiana
Housing Finance Agency will work together each year to propose affordability targets for
specific numbers of housing units, integrate their targets into the annual Qualified
Allocation Plan criteria for the LIHTC program, and set aside CDBG funds to be
matched to those tax credit goals to meet overall program objectives. These officers will
likewise evaluate actual numbers of units delivered annually. In the event of any
shortfall versus those targets during a calendar year, those funds and targets will be
added to the subsequent year's goals and allocations.
The State will direct that strong preference be given by development groups which are
awarded Piggyback incentives to offer their properties to hurricane-displaced renters
from the affected areas of Louisiana. In doing so, the State will require that developers
promote their available units through the proposed Renter's Registry described Section
3.5 below.
3.2 Services Funding for Supportive Housing
Under the partially funded plan, the State intends to use CDBG funds or other financial
resources that can be obtained to fund supportive services for approximately 1,870
22
supportive housing units, the development of which will be financed by the LIHTC and
CDBG piggyback program described above. Under the fully funded program, the
program will support an estimated 3,000 units with supportive housing services. Other
HUD programs such as the McKinney Vento Act, Project Based Section 8 Vouchers,
Section 811, and Section 202 program funds may supplement supportive efforts.
The supportive housing units will serve individuals and families with special needs, most
importantly, renter households who are returning to Louisiana after having endured,
very often, traumatic relocations from shelter to shelter, to hotels, and to other
temporary living arrangements in other cities. Supportive housing units are also needed
for returning families and individuals who are disabled, frail elderly, or have other
special needs.
Supportive services will be provided in 30% of the 6,000 to 9,000 rental units targeted to
households with incomes at or below 40% of area median income. In order to provide
that level of services, the State proposes to allocate $46,750,0009 of the currently
available CDBG funds to help pay for the services. This program component and use of
CDBG funds for supportive services is proposed with the recognition that the number of
supportive housing units that can be developed in Louisiana over the next few years will
be severely limited by the scarcity of public and private funding for the necessary
resident services.
When the expected $4.2 billion in additional CDBG funds are appropriated for The Road
Home, the budget for supportive housing services will be increased to $72,730,000 to
fund services for an estimated 3,000 units.
3.3 Flexible Incentives for Mixed-Income Development
For mixed-income residential developments to occur on a larger scale-even if the
affordable housing units are receiving supplemental CDBG funding as described
above-the State recognizes that additional incentives may be required in certain
instances to successfully promote market-rate housing to be mixed with affordable
housing. Therefore, the State proposes to use $41,560,000 of CDBG funds to
supplement mixed-income housing projects. These flexible subsidies will be used
primarily in conjunction with the LIHTC incentives, but they will also be available for
other projects offering rents or sale prices affordable to families both above and below
80% of AMI.
The primary mechanism for providing these incentives will be recoverable grants
provided to reduce the costs of land and infrastructure. Such grants will be offered on a
competitive basis. Grants will be made subject to requirements that will be specific to
each project, such as minimum requirements for providing a mix of rents or sale prices.
9 Assumes 1,870 units with services costing an average of $5,000 per unit per year over five years.
23
Grants will be recovered if all mixed-income requirements set for selected projects are
not met. Operating costs of this program will be covered through operating budgets for
other housing programs described herein, such as the CDBG/LIHTC Piggyback
Program or the Housing Development Loan Fund.
3.4 Small Rental Property Repair Program
Before the disaster, a large portion of very low income working families resided in
single-family homes, "doubles" and small, multi-family buildings with ten or fewer units
that were owned and operated by small-scale landlords. A sizeable number of these
properties were underinsured or uninsured and no longer available for occupancy. The
State proposes to provide gap financing for the repair of an estimated 10,500 small
rental units in the partially funded program, and an estimated 18,000 rental housing
units when the program is fully funded. The primary purposes of the gap financing are to
enable repairs to occur and to limit the amount of debt (and therefore debt service)
required for the properties, so that the owners will be able to charge affordable rents.
The program will, on a competitive basis, provide gap financing up to $25,000 to restore
a rental unit renting at Fair Market Rental rates according to HUD guidelines, with
higher funding amounts up to $75,000 per unit available to qualified landlords who
agree to offer lower rents, with the maximum amount of subsidy going for rental units
where rents are affordable for families with incomes at or below 50% AMI. To spark
immediate development of scattered properties of all rent levels, units offered at Fair
Market Rental rates will be eligible for assistance, but only for the first tier of assistance
of up to $25,000 of incentives. Eligible properties will be selected based upon a strong
preference for well-designed residential communities and infill housing developments
that also include families with incomes higher than the area median. Further, each
application should be scrutinized by underwriters in light of the criteria and proposed
project costs. The State should negotiate with applicants to seek the best possible
outcomes for each project.
In exchange for accepting financial incentives, property owners will be required to
accept limitations on rents (with inflation clauses) and incomes of renters for a period of
10 years, to assure that the assisted housing is as affordable as possible and is
occupied by families with incomes corresponding to several tiers of affordable rents.
The amount of CDBG financing available will be provided in three tiers-$25,000 ,
$50,000 and $75,000 per unit-with the highest amount per unit being available to
property owners who agree to offer the lowest rents. The assistance will be offered as
deferred payment loans at 0% interest, due only upon resale of the property or failure to
comply with the agreed-upon restrictions on rents and household incomes.
The tiers with affordability requirements, representing two thirds of the program funds,
are expected to produce roughly 12,000 units when the program is fully funded.
24
As with the homeowner program, small rental property owners will have access to
expert financial and construction advisors to assist them with refinancing and
reconstruction, or if they so desire, to sell their properties to developers using the LIHTC
program.
Unlike the homeowner program, funds will be insufficient to provide every small-scale
property owner with enough money to repair or replace their rental properties.
Prioritization of properties that will be selected for assistance will be based on factors
including, but not limited to, the following:
• Property owners demonstrating financial and technical capacity to obtain matching
market-rate financing, if necessary, to carry out the repairs, and to provide
excellent property management services; and
• Properties that are most cost-effective to repair or replace, and located in areas
that have adequate infrastructure and redevelopment activities occurring.
• Properties held by small-scale landlords where rental revenue constituted a
majority of household income and/or assets so long as these investor-owners
meet the threshold requirements for capacity necessary to repair or replace, and
then manage their units.
As outlined in the Homeowner Assistance Program guidelines, owner-occupant
program assistance and small rental property assistance cannot be combined in the
same residential property. Where an owner-occupant rents units within a multi-unit
structure, the owner must choose to participate in one program or the other. If the
Homeowner Assistance Program is chosen, the full double-unit structure will serve as
the basis for calculation of assistance up to the program cap of $150,000. For all other
owner-occupied multi-unit structures, funding up to $150,000 is available but is based
on the damages to and value of the unit in which the owner resides. If the owner
selects the Small Rental Property Repair Program and the owner is selected for
assistance, assistance to each unit, including the owner-occupied unit, will be limited to
$25,000 to $75,000, as with all units under the program application, dependent on
affordability levels on each rental unit.
The landlord applying for the Small Rental Property Repair Program will be able to
receive incentives for a unit in the property in which he or she is an owner-occupant.
The formula for the amount of CDBG funding per rental unit is as follows:
Eligible Assistance per Rental Unit = Lesser of:
• Allowable Rebuilding Costs + Mitigation Costs (minus)
Insurance (minus) Maximum private financing the
property rents will support
OR
• The Maximum CDBG funding amount described above
25
To the extent that property owners do not request or qualify for the higher amounts of
funding per unit, the program will be able to support the repair of more rental units,
albeit at higher rents.
The LRA also proposes to allow variations of this program that will provide incentives,
not only for repairing damaged rental properties, but converting them to owner-occupied
housing. Two pilot programs may be created and expanded if successful. The first pilot
program could allow a landlord to sell a repaired one-family or two-family rental property
to a low- or moderate-income homeowner, rather than rent the home. The second pilot
program would allow low- and moderate-income homebuyers to purchase unrepaired
one-family and two-family rental units and to carry the home through the repair process.
Creating first-time homebuyers will be a priority but the pilot program will also serve
buyers who have previously owned homes. Homeowners who are exercising the "sell"
or "relocate" option may not receive additional financial assistance from the state
through either of these pilot programs. These pilot programs will be funded through the
budget for the Small Rental Property Rental Program. The incentives will be tiered
similarly as above (based on the income of the first occupants), and the rental
affordability requirements (for any rental units in two-family homes) will remain the
same.
A total of $492,700,000 is budgeted for the Small Rental Property Repair Program
under the partially funded budget, including program operating costs. Upon the
additional appropriation of $4.2 billion by Congress, the budget for this competitive
program will increase to $869,000,000.
3.5 Renters' Registry
Because the replacement of rental housing will fall far short of the rental housing lost
due to insufficient funds, and many residents displaced by hurricanes Rita and Katrina
are far from home and inadequately housed, the State will give priority placement to
hurricane displaced residents for all subsidized rental housing units.
A total of $2 million in CDBG funds has been budgeted to provide the following
resources to displaced renters to help facilitate their return home:
?? Louisiana has initiated a Call Center and Homeowner Registry to allow former
homeowners to indicate their interest in returning to their neighborhoods and
investing in their homes. The Call Center/Registry will add a component for
renters to gather information about the current location of displaced renters who
wish to return home. Initially, the Call Center/Registry will refer callers to
emergency housing assistance resources posted on the web portal at
www.LouisianaRebuilds.info. As new or repaired subsidized affordable rental
units come on line, renters will be referred to a web data base where affordable
26
rental housing is listed, and where they can access applications for incomeassisted
housing.
?? When the database referral system commences, eligible renters will be notified
by mail, telephone, and the www.LouisianaRebuilds.info web portal to the
greatest extent possible of the opportunity to access rental information and apply
for assistance. Information about rental programs will be posted on public
websites and at Housing Assistance Centers.
4. Restoration of Homeless Supports and Housing
The State is proposing $25,900,000 of CDBG funds be allocated to address increased
risks and demands related to homelessness. In hurricane-impacted areas, many
organizations serving the homeless lost facilities, housing capacity, shelter beds, and
staff: Thirty-six shelters sustained considerable damage, and capacity to house up to
1,759 homeless individuals (i.e., 1,759 residential "beds" operated by "Continuum of
Care" organizations serving the homeless) was lost. In hurricane-impacted areas, there
are reports that an increased number of persons are living on the streets or in parks,
cars, and abandoned or uninhabitable buildings. Many of these persons were not
homeless prior to the storms. Additionally, many older adults and persons with
disabilities who resided in the community prior to the storms are currently being housed
in nursing homes and other institutions, and many residents cannot be discharged or
transitioned from these settings due to the lack of affordable, barrier-free, and/or
supportive housing. These funds will assist in providing a safe and permanent place for
homeless and at risk of homeless individuals to reside and get the supportive services
they need to remain housed and to be as independent and self-sufficient as possible.
The proposed $25.9 million will support the State's goal to immediately restore and
expand capacity in hurricane impacted areas and provide permanent supportive
housing and assistance for persons and families who are homeless and persons at-risk
of becoming homeless who are low wage workers, unemployed, victims of domestic
violence, low-income seniors, and/or low-income persons with any type of substantial
disability (including physical or sensory disability, cognitive disability, chronic health
problems, mental illness, or addictive disorders).
The proposal allows for funding to be prioritized as follows:
The highest priority for the use of these funds will be to repair and restore shelter
capacity, transitional housing and permanent supportive housing that existed prior to
Hurricanes Katrina and Rita. The cost of restoring this capacity is estimated to be $3
million to $5 million. Priority for these funds will be given to members of the Continuums
of Care. Non-member organizations may apply for funding but should document prestorm
homeless efforts in the community and indicate a commitment to coordinating
with the local Continuums of Care upon receipt of these funds.
27
A second priority will be the acquisition and rehabilitation of new permanent supportive
housing and services by non-profits in the hurricane-affected areas. This priority also
includes the option of funding rental assistance (i.e., "bridge funding") linked to
permanent supportive housing. The prioritization of non-profits is based on the
understanding that some non-profit groups working with homeless and at-risk
populations will not have the capacity to apply for tax credits and supportive services
funds through the "piggyback" program
The third priority will be homeless prevention assistance to serve the hurricane affected
areas, however not to duplicate any existing federal subsidies for this purpose. This
priority includes traditional homeless prevention - such as funding the first month of
rental assistance to avoid homelessness - as well as innovative practices to prevent
homelessness, such as home modifications, repairs not covered by other parts of the
Road Home program, and other supports that help individuals maintain residency in
their home.
The fourth priority is the funding of new transitional housing and services targeted
particularly for families who have experienced significant trauma as a result of the
hurricanes and need the support of transitional housing rather than the groups
addressed in the permanent supportive housing initiatives listed in the second priority.
The fifth priority is the creation and expansion of employment and housing search
services for the homeless in the hurricane affected areas. These funded efforts should
be in coordination with and non-duplicative of other recovery related employment and
housing efforts such as the Louisiana Family Recovery Corps. Applicants will propose
a mechanism to ensure that individuals will not receive duplicative services.
5. Developer Incentives
The State recognizes that communities that lost the most housing due to the Katrina
and Rita disasters will need to have special incentives in place to attract new mixedincome
housing development-to restore both the rental and owner-occupied housing
stocks. Homeowners who elect to take the relocation option will make it necessary to
have a steady and large supply of new homes. Therefore, the following developer
incentives are proposed, with a special focus on the New Orleans metropolitan areas
and other communities with major losses to their housing stock.
These programs and financial tools described in Section 5, and working in combination
with the Workforce and Affordable Rental Housing Programs in Section 3, are proposed
as a well-orchestrated toolkit that-working together-are more likely to encourage
developers to rebuild housing in the areas that suffered the greatest losses. All are
intended to address very specific barriers: Lack of affordable, permanent financing for
mixed-income rentals; the need for more risk-tolerant predevelopment capital; and the
lack of available sites for development where housing development is most needed.
28
The budget for incentives is provided in the table below:
Development Incentives
Program Partially Funded Fully Funded
Development Loan Fund $16,570,000 $16,570,000
Land Assembly $2,070,000 $2,070,000
Capacity Building Grants $2,070,000 $2,070,000
Building Code
Enforcement
$11,390,000 $11,390,000
TOTAL $32,100,000 $32,100,000
5.1 Housing Development Loan Fund
The Housing Development Loan Fund would provide seed funding for a contractor or
state agency to establish one or more loan funds that offer acquisition and
predevelopment financing on flexible terms to developers of the most critically needed
housing. Providing early, high-risk capital will be a powerful incentive for developers to
build mixed-income housing in the communities that lost the most housing. Loans would
be made to nonprofit and for-profit developers of new rental and single-family housing
that is affordable to families with incomes that are below the area median, with a strong
preference for well-designed residential communities and infill housing developments
that also include families with incomes higher than the area median.
The Housing Development Loan Fund would be operated by a state agency or an
experienced community development loan fund manager. A total of $16,570,000 in
CDBG funds, including fund management costs, will be invested as "top loss" capital in
order to leverage an estimated $30 million in additional lending capital. As two priorities,
the loan fund would target developers participating in the rental assistance programs
described in the previous section, as well as developers of mixed-income for-sale
housing. As projects close their construction financing, the acquisition/predevelopment
loans would be repaid and the lending capital would become available for additional
investments. In a three-year period, it is expected that the funds will recycle two to three
times.
As currently planned, the Housing Development Loan Fund would be operated on a
contractual basis by one or more qualified financial institutions that are experienced in
providing early-stage, high-risk property acquisition and predevelopment loans, as an
incentive for developers to rebuild existing housing or build new housing at different
price points, including affordable homes and rental units. These types of loans are
typically not offered by conventional lenders, but instead by the numerous so-called
"community development loan funds" across the country. These loan funds are able to
take higher risks in lending by attracting risk-tolerant capital and guarantees from
foundations and socially motivated investors. The goal should be to lend the funds at
0% and to subordinate these loans to the private capital in order to provide a strong
incentive for developers and to leverage private capital. Many such funds receive some
29
of their capital as grants from the Community Development Financial Institutions (CDFI)
Fund of the Department of Treasury.
Congress specifically directed the states receiving supplemental CDBG funding should
consider the use of up to $20 million to fund recovery activities of two organizations that
are experienced in operating such loan funds: Enterprise Community Partners, Inc.,
and Local Initiatives Support Corporation.
5.2 Land Assembly Operations
As an additional way to jump-start development in the communities that lost the most
housing, the Land Assembly component of the housing program will provide seed
money to acquire multiple properties in good locations for replacement housing and
"package" them for sale or grant to maximize further affordable housing development-
for example, to developers using CDBG-supported LIHTC tax incentives to develop
rental housing, to supportive housing developers, to self-help ownership housing
developers, etc. This program component will operate only in those jurisdictions where:
?? These activities are requested or supported by local governments; and
?? Local governments have substantially engaged in the planning work required to
target areas that are suitable for the development of replacement housing.
A total of $2,070,000 of CDBG funds are budgeted for capital to purchase residential
properties as well as operating costs. The capital used to purchase properties will be
recycled through sales of properties to developers.
As a related activity, properties assembled through buy-out programs, funded through
the State's homeowner assistance program, might be offered at below-market costs to
developers of affordable or special needs housing. One of the targets of these sales of
State-purchased properties would be to encourage the development of mixed income
developments that include renters with incomes below 40% of area median income. If
such assembled properties were not purchased and developed by affordable
developers in accordance with strict income requirements, they still might carry an
inclusionary housing redevelopment requirement that a certain percentage of the units
developed on CDBG assembled land would be affordable with less stringent income
and pricing requirements, but still ensuring that mixed-income developments occur in
redevelopment areas.
However, the $2 million Land Assembly fund is fundamentally different from and should
not be confused with the buyout provisions of the Homeowner Assistance Program.
This budget line item is not intended for purchases of single-family homes. Instead, the
intention is to contract out to one or more qualified organizations that can identify
suitable sites for housing development in the most distressed parishes and obtain
30
options on them. The intention is to address a complicating barrier to housing
developments: the lack of-and high asking prices for-suitable sites that are near
functioning infrastructure and services (public services, retail etc.). The State intends,
through contractual arrangements, to fund a small team of property acquisition experts
who will scout out, analyze and obtain options on suitable sites that are not currently on
the open market. These could include surplus properties held by government agencies,
nonprofits, churches and businesses. Some might be brownfield sites that could be
cleaned up quickly and at feasible costs. This Land Assembly operation would result in
assignable options in the name of the State of Louisiana or some designated quasipublic
entity. These options, in turn, would be offered to developers on an
open, competitive basis.
This Land Assembly operation should not be viewed in isolation. It ties into the
Louisiana Housing Finance Agency's LIHTC program, the proposed CDBG/LIHTC
Piggyback program, the Services Funding for Supportive Housing program, and the
Housing Development Loan Fund.
5.3 Support for Faith-Based and Community-Based Housing Recovery Programs
The State aims to strengthen community nonprofits and faith institutions already
providing housing recovery services through the investment of $2,070,000 of CDBG
funds in their activities. These entities may have opportunities to contract to provide
some services in Housing Assistance Centers. They will be eligible to apply for grants to
build capacity in providing supportive housing services. They will be eligible to apply for
matching grants to supplement charitable fundraising they have done for housing
recovery assisting low and moderate income homeowners in repairing or replacing their
homes, as well as for seed money to develop repair and replacement housing for low
and moderate income households.
These organizations will be encouraged to help expand the supply of supportive
housing, affordable rental housing and affordable homes for sale by participating, as
qualified, in program such as the LIHTC program, the CDBG piggyback program, the
small rental program (if a nonprofit wishes to buy, repair and operate affordable rental
properties), the flexible incentives program, and the Housing Development Loan Fund.
5.4 Funding of Building Code Enforcement by Local Governments
Without special assistance being provided to local governments, it is expected that a
major impediment to housing development will be the lack of building, electrical and
plumbing inspectors and permit processing staff. In addition, architects and builders will
need inspectors and plan reviewers to help communities adapt to the new State Uniform
Construction Code and to interpret the latest available advisory base flood elevations.
Therefore, the State has budgeted $11,390,000 for hiring such staff for local
government over a number of years, based on the numbers of damaged/destroyed units
in each parish. It is expected that this amount will fund at least 40 field inspectors and
31
plan reviewers, as well as a limited number of support staff. The State will also support
the expansion of code enforcement capacity by sponsoring additional training
opportunities for inspectors, engineers and architects. While building code enforcement
by local authorities will be supported by permitting and inspection fees in the long run,
this initial CDBG funding is necessary to immediately expand enforcement capacity to
expedite the construction of safer and stronger homes where the storm impact was
most concentrated and building activity will be fervent in coming months.
6. Administration
With this amendment, the State is requesting a total of $148.68 million under current,
partial funding levels, which includes the $8,810,400 requested in the first action plan
and $189.880 when the program is fully funded.
7. Planning
With this amendment, the State is requesting $9.5 million of which $0 was requested in
the first action plan.
8. Technical Assistance
With this amendment, the State is requesting $12.420 million, of which $500,000 was
requested in the first action plan.
9. Other Requirements
9.1 Fair Housing Goals
Fair housing must be a goal of the programs described in The Road Home Housing
Program. If a homeowner or renter (from a unit developed through the benefits of this
program) believes that he or she has been the victim of housing discrimination and
suspects that he or she has been treated unfairly because of Race, Color, Religion,
Sex, Age, Familial Status, National Origin, Marital Status, or Disability, he or she may
file a complaint of discrimination with the Louisiana Attorney General's Office, Louisiana
Public Protection Division of the US Department of Housing and Urban Development
Fair Housing Division.
9.2 Program Income
32
Because the allocation of federal resources will not meet the entire need for housing
replacement in Louisiana, and because the costs of replacement housing are escalating
in the storm-impacted areas, the State will recycle all income from sales of properties,
repayments of any program loans, funds recaptured through violations of guidelines,
covenants, or other actions, and any collections of lien payments derived through
actions of these CDBG housing programs. From a regulatory standpoint, recycled
CDBG funds can be used for any eligible CDBG activity as described in the State's
Annual Plans. The revenue generated by the program can effectively be used to
achieve focused long-term housing goals by dedicating and restricting the use of
recycled housing funds for future affordable housing programs. This could, in effect,
create a revenue stream for the Louisiana Permanent Housing Trust Fund., which could
be administered by a public or quasi-public agency at the state or local government
levels. The policies shaping the housing reuse of revenues will be made at a later date,
as detailed operational plans are being developed, but will continue to prioritize
displaced residents and deeply affordable rental housing, and will help to sustain
affordability as terms expire in many of the properties supported through the programs
articulated herein in 10 to 15 20 years.
9.3 Promotion of Short- and Long-Term Recovery Planning
To promote sound short- and long-term recovery planning at the state and local levels
that impact land use decisions that reflect the need for responsible flood plain
management and growth, the State, through the Louisiana Recovery Authority, is
leading community planning efforts in its most affected parishes. Dubbed "Louisiana
Speaks", this effort is a multifaceted planning process to develop a sustainable, longterm
vision for South Louisiana in the wake of the destruction caused by Hurricanes
Katrina and Rita. The community planning process accomplishes the following:
?? Supports a deliberate and democratic process that relies on active participation;
?? Empowers local communities to develop plans that meet individual needs;
?? Establishes priorities at the local level to guide decisions;
?? Supports communities with the best national planning experts working in
partnership with local architects, planners, and engineers; and
?? Provides a user-friendly interface to enable development of individual plans.
The goal of the long-term community planning process is to develop a comprehensive
plan that integrates both parish plans (coordinated with the support of FEMA technical
assistance) and regional recovery plans. The LRA collaborated with planners from
FEMA to develop a parish level planning process to address numerous recovery issues
pertinent to the long-term recovery of severely damaged parishes. A total of 26
parishes throughout Louisiana were identified to participate in this planning process,
which runs from November 2005 through April 2006. Louisiana Recovery Planning Day
was an important part of the parish level planning process. On January 21, 2006, which
was proclaimed Louisiana Recovery Planning Day by Governor Kathleen Babineaux
Blanco, the Louisiana Recovery Authority (LRA) and FEMA's Long-Term Community
Recovery (LTCR) team hosted a series of open houses to provide Louisianans with an
33
opportunity to express their needs and to help define a community-based vision for
Louisiana's recovery.
The parish level planning process will result in the development of initial parish recovery
plans, which will be used to set funding priorities for the recovery effort. The final plans
will include a community baseline, a needs assessment, a recovery strategy including
principles, vision, goals, a set of high value recovery projects and a strategic recovery
timeline. The final section will describe opportunities for the integration of the local plan
with regional and statewide plans. The section will also include an inventory of local
resources, government structures and describe the level of technical expertise needed
to implement the plan. Emphasis in the planning process is on developing plans that
are based on sound land use practices and plans that remain cognizant of the hazards
of rebuilding in areas made more risky by new flood guidelines.
For a more detailed description of Louisiana's long-term and short-term recovery
planning efforts, please visit:
http://www.louisianaspeaks.org/process.html
9.4 High Quality Construction Methods
In a special legislative session in November 2005, Louisiana enacted its first statewide
building code. The law states: "The state uniform construction code shall establish
uniform performance standards providing reasonable safeguards for health, safety,
welfare, comfort, and security balanced with affordability for the residents of this state
who are occupants and users of buildings, and will provide for the use of modern
methods, devices, materials, and techniques. The state uniform construction code will
encourage the use of construction materials of the greatest durability, lower long-term
costs, and provide greater storm resistance." The programs described in this Action
Plan Amendment will adhere to this directive of the Louisiana Legislature.
The State Uniform Construction Code (UCC) sets a minimum statewide standard to
ensure the homes and businesses are rebuilt to withstand the next hurricane. The LRA
and other agencies of state government urge jurisdictions, especially those along the
coast, to adopt all building safety standards in the UCC. Most coastal communities
have begun to enforce the UCC; the entire state must do so on January 1, 2007.
Regardless of the location, however, it remains the State's commitment to rebuild safer
and stronger communities, so all homeowner assistance provided by The Road Home
will be contingent upon enforcement of the code on homes built with program funds.
The state has high standards for energy efficiency in buildings. The State Uniform
Construction Code includes a provision requiring energy saving construction provisions.
Act 12 specifically references the provisions of the International Residential Code which
give direction regarding energy efficiency.
34
Where it is cost effective and improves the quality and sustainability of housing
construction under the programs of this Action Plan Amendment, the State will
encourage mold resistant construction, including modern methods, devices, materials,
and techniques as directed by the State Uniform Construction Code.
RS 51:911.22 and RS 51:911.21 of the Louisiana Revised Statutes contain standards
relative to manufactured housing construction and installation.
Louisiana has adopted HUD standards under the National Manufactured Housing
Construction and Safety Standards Act of 1974, as amended.
Where it is cost effective to do so, the programs in this Action Plan Amendment will
emphasize the quality and sustainability of housing construction, adhering to
sustainable construction techniques emphasized by the federal government. These
federal standards for sustainable construction techniques include:
• Optimizing site potential, including in ways that strengthen neighborhoods,
promote economic opportunity, and improve transportation;
• Protecting and conserving natural resources, including water, materials, and the
atmosphere;
• Expanding renewable energy consumption, and ultimately create net energy;
• Effectively and efficiently using materials, and ultimately recover materials for use
in new products and services;
• Providing a safe, healthy, and productive built environment for inhabitants and
users;
• Reducing facility life-cycle costs and optimizing operations and maintenance
costs; and
• Using green products and services.
9.5 Monitoring
The OCD/DOA and the LRA will hire additional employees to carry out the
administrative functions associated with the implementation and monitoring of the
housing programs. The OCD has the staff expertise to train additional employees on
the federal and state regulations governing the CDBG program. In addition, the State
has contracted with ICF Consulting to provide additional training to staff, contractors,
counselors, etc. The LRA has a mandate from the Governor and Louisiana Legislature
to assure the coordinated use of resources toward the recovery and to support the most
efficient and effective use of such resources. The OCD and the LRA will work together
to achieve this goal.
The State has a monitoring plan for the regular CDBG program and will develop a
monitoring guide for staff and contractors for each housing program. The plan will be
revised somewhat to accommodate the waivers given to the State and other provisions
cited in the legislation. The State has contracted with ICF to assist in the development
35
of a monitoring plan for all housing related programs. Particular attention will be paid to
ensuring that the use of funds are disaster related and that funding allocated will not
duplicate other benefits. The State will ensure through its design of programs,
application process, monitoring of recipients, and oversight by the LRA Board's Audit
Committee, that recipients are not receiving duplication of benefits and that funds are
not used for projects or activities that are reimbursable by or for which funds have been
made available by FEMA or by the Army Corps of Engineers and are abiding by state
and federal regulations. The State, drawing upon the resources of the LRA and under
its guidance, will coordinate with FEMA, the Army Corps of Engineers, insurance
companies, and other entities during the application process to ensure there is no
duplication of benefits. Recipients will be asked to sign a waiver of their privacy rights
so that the State can obtain the appropriate information from FEMA and all other federal
agencies.
The State shall hire an independent firm to assist the State in its efforts to achieve the
community benefit requirements of the U. S. Department of Housing and Urban
Development and in verifying that programs are meeting their required targets including
the provisions of Section 3. The firm shall report to OCD and LRA on progress towards
meeting the community benefit requirements. The firm shall also provide community
outreach to low and moderate income citizens to apprise them of the recovery
assistance programs available to them including but not limited to housing programs
and the benefits of the Section 3 provisions.
The State is in the process of developing a Request for Proposal to provide program
management services for the homeowner and rental programs detailed in this Action
Plan amendment. The proposal will seek the best available management firm to assist
in the implementation of these programs. The State will have staff assigned to monitor
the services being provided under the contract.
9.6 Mitigation of Fraud, Waste and Mismanagement
The State has a number of processes and procedures in place to avoid fraud, abuse
and mismanagement. The Legislative Auditor serves as the watchdog of public
spending, overseeing more than 3,500 audits of state and local governments and their
related quasi-public enterprises. Conducting independent financial and performance
audits of the State's agencies, colleges, and universities, auditors find ways to improve
government and identify critical issues to protect public resources and tighten
government control systems. When necessary, they follow up on allegations of fraud,
waste, or abuse. The Legislative Auditor will perform an annual audit of the DOA in
accordance with A-133.
In addition, the State has an established Office of the Inspector General. The office's
mission is to help prevent waste, mismanagement, abuse, fraud and corruption in the
executive branch of state government without regard to partisan politics, allegiances,
status, or influence. The Inspector General is appointed by the Governor.
36
The LRA Board has established an Audit Committee which, in conjunction with its LRA
staff, is charged with ensuring that the work of the recovery is conducted in a manner
consistent with the highest ethical standards. Throughout the recovery, the LRA Audit
Committee and staff will receive and review reports from all governmental entities
working to detect, prevent, and eliminate instances of fraud and abuse. It will serve as
the body to bring together multiple audit and oversight groups to provide an
independent review of the audit efforts themselves.
The Office of Finance and Support Services (OFSS), a section of the DOA, has
established clear designation of responsibilities in order to ensure separation of duties.
This separation of duties, along with other established operational policies and
procedures, provides assurance that fraud cannot be accomplished without collusion
among employees in separate areas.
The OFSS is responsible for payments, federal draw down requests, and state and
federal financial reporting. The OCD is responsible for the day to day administration of
the CDBG program. Their staff reviews all requests for payment and accompanying
invoices to ensure costs are reasonable and within the scope of the activity funded.
Two signatures are required on a request for payment prior to being sent to OFSS for
payment. All payment requests are reviewed for proper authorized signatures prior to
input into the financial system for payment. One employee actually inputs the properly
authorized payment request into the financial system and the request must be approved
in the system by the payment unit supervisor. Through financial system security, no
one person can both input and approve a payment request.
The payment management unit of OFSS provides information to the appropriation
accounting unit so that federal funds can be drawn. The federal draw down request is
reviewed and approved by a supervisor prior to the draw down request being
processed. All funds are electronically transferred to the State Treasurer's central
depository account to be used to liquidate the payables. The financial reporting of the
expenditure and revenue activities is prepared by the appropriation accounting unit. All
reports are prepared by one employee and reviewed by the appropriate manager prior
to release of the report/statement.
In addition, the State will hire an internal auditor who will be placed within the OCD to
oversee the internal functions of this office. The auditor will report to the Commissioner
of Administration and will make reports to the LRA Audit Committee as requested.
The State follows the State Procurement Code and all other sub recipients are required
to follow Title 24 Part 84 and Part 85. The monitoring plan outlines the requirements
that must be followed.
Training and technical assistance will be provided to local governments, contractors,
and any other entity responsible for administering activities under this grant.
9.7 Mitigation of Flood Hazards
37
To mitigate flood risk, the LRA approved an allocation of $250 million in hazard
mitigation funding to help parishes prevent damage from future disasters. Following
approval of the Legislature, the Louisiana Recovery Authority (LRA) authorized the use
of $150 million to help parishes prevent damage from future disasters by directing the
Governor's Office of Homeland Security and Emergency Preparedness (GOSHEP) to
distribute the first hazard mitigation funding available after Hurricanes Katrina and Rita
to parish governments.
According to the formula approved by the LRA:
?? $100 million will be dedicated to elevate and acquire severe repetitive loss
properties.
?? $136 million for other cost-effective acquisition or elevation projects, or for
the retrofit of critical facilities.
?? $14 million for mitigation planning and education.
The LRA has passed resolutions tying benefits and funding for communities and
parishes to the adoption of the most up-to-date flood guidance as part of their floodplain
management ordinances. The LRA has said it will only provide HMGP and CDBG
funding in those parishes that adhere to the State's new building codes and adopt and
enforce FEMA's Base Flood Elevation guidance in the construction or reconstruction of
all homes, businesses, and other structures in the aftermath of Hurricanes Katrina and
Rita
The LRA determined overall priorities for the use of HMGP funds that will serve as a
tool for elevating projects for funding
The LRA also directed GOHSEP to prepare an application for HMGP funds for a fiveyear
hazard mitigation outreach and education campaign aimed at educating Louisiana
citizens, businesses and units of government about the best use of mitigation dollars
About 1,700 homes, or about one-third of the severely and repetitively damaged homes
in America, are in Louisiana. These are structures that have suffered damages of
$1,000 or more on at least four occasions, or have suffered damages of more than 50
percent of their value on two or more occasions.
To access these hazard mitigation funds, parishes will submit proposals to OHSEP. The
funds, which are provided under the Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance
Act, require a 25 percent match from parish governments or state agencies. Distribution
of these funds is subject to a formal review process in accordance with the Inspector
General, Legislative Auditor, Commissioner of Administration and State Treasurer, as
has been done for all funds distributed by GOSHEP since Hurricanes Katrina and Rita.
9.8 Encouragement of Energy Efficiency and Sound Environmental Practices
38
The State will encourage energy efficiency through implementation of its new state
housing codes that include provisions for energy efficient repairs and construction.
Further, the State will provide technical assistance to local governments and private and
for profit developers to educate them on sound practices for eradication of mold and use
of mold resistant materials and construction techniques.
9.9 Removal of Barriers to Reconstruction
Through the proposed Housing Assistance Centers the State will encourage expedited
processing of assistance applications, permits for new construction, and constructions
inspection. The staff of the Assistance Centers will provide feedback to the State on
challenges they are encountering that interfere with the repair and production of
housing. Based on the challenges identified, the State will work with local governments
to expedite investments.
39
APPENDICES
40
APPENDIX 1
ACTION PLAN FEEDBACK FORMAT
First Name:
Last Name:
Organization:
Mailing Address:
Street 1
Street 2
City State Zip code
Phone Number:
E-mail Address:
May we contact you if we have questions about your comments? Yes No
Affiliation: Check any of the following that apply. Are you a:
Evacuee___
Homeowner whose property was damaged ___
Rental Property owner whose property was damaged ___
Local government official ___
Real estate industry professional ____
Other _________________________________________
Comments on Owner Occupied Programs:
1. Eligibility of Homeowners to receive assistance
2. Requirements for receiving homeowner assistance
3. Financial benefits for homeowners to repair and rebuild
4. Financial benefits for homeowners who resettle
5. Financial benefits for homeowners who elect to sell their homes and move away
6. Homeowners assistance centers and program administration
7. Please provide any additional comments that you have on the owner occupant program
Comments on Rental Housing Programs
8. Low-Income Housing "Piggyback" rental program
9. Small scale rental repair program
Comments on Homeless and Supportive Service Program
10. Supportive services housing program
41
11. Homeless shelter repair program
Comments on Other Developer Incentives
12. Housing Development Loan Fund
13. Land assembly initiative
14. Flexible Subsidies - Mixed Income
Other
15. Please provide your comments on other aspects of the Action Plan amendment of
concern to you
42
APPENDIX 2
SAMPLE BENEFIT CALCULATIONS
Case 1 - Insured retired couple
An older couple owns a home with a pre-storm value of $153,000. They bought the house for
$50,000 in 1970 and had not increased their insurance coverage. After receiving an insurance
award of $50,000 and a FEMA assistance grant of $10,500, they still have $17,530 in
uninsured damages. What are their options under The Road Home housing plan?
Homeowner Summary
Pre-storm Value: $153,000
Loss to Home: $153,000 x 51% = $78,030
Insurance: $50,000
FEMA Assistance: $10,500
Cost to elevate home to meet FEMA standards: $30,000
Repair or Rebuild
Eligible Road Home Grant Award = $78,030 - $50,000 - $10,500 = $17,530
Hazard mitigation grant = $30,000
Summary of Costs / Losses Summary of benefits
Damage to Home:
Additional Mitigation Costs:
Total
$78,030
$30,000
$108,030
Insurance:
FEMA:
Road Home:
Mitigation:
Total
$50,000
$10,500
$17,530
$30,000
$108,030
Note: Homeowners may be eligible for an affordable loan to cover the gap if there is a difference
between repair costs and the grant they receive.
Relocate/Buyout
If they want to sell the rights to their home and move somewhere else in Louisiana, the state will
pay them up to the amount of their damages, based on the pre-storm value of their home. They
also may be eligible for an affordable loan to cover the gap if there is a difference between repair
costs and the grant they receive. The grant and loan amounts would be the same as under the
"repair/rebuild" model.
Eligible Road Home Grant Award = $78,030 - $50,000 - $10,500 = $17,530
Summary of Costs / Losses Summary of benefits
43
Damage to Home: $78,030
Insurance:
FEMA:
Road Home:
Total
$50,000
$10,500
$17,530
$78,030
Note: If required, hazard mitigation funds will be available at the new location. Total Road
Home assistance, including hazard mitigation funds and loan, cannot exceed $150,000.
Sell
If they wish to move somewhere outside of Louisiana, the state will buy their home for 60
percent of its pre-storm value or the amount of eligible assistance under the repair/rebuild
program, whichever is less.
Seller would receive lesser of:
Pre-storm Value: $153,000 X 60% = $91,800
OR
Eligible Road Home Grant under Repair/Rebuild : $17,530
Summary of Costs / Losses Summary of benefits
Pre-storm value of home
sold: $153,000
Insurance:
FEMA:
Road Home:
Total
$50,000
$10,500
$17,530
$78,030
In this case, the seller who relocates out of state is out the difference of $153,000 - $78,030 =
$74,970. The LRA acknowledges that the sell option is generally the least favorable; however,
the goal of the Road Home program is to encourage our citizens to revitalize our communities
here in Louisiana. A more favorable option financially for the homeowner choosing "Sell" could
be to choose to repair to return the property to its original condition, use the assignability option,
and then sell the property on the open market to a new resident homeowner that will agree to the
covenants of the program.
Case 2 - Uninsured single parent
A single parent who inherited a home with a pre-storm value of $110,000 had a damage loss of
30%. She was uninsured and did not pay premiums over the years like her neighbors. She
received a check from FEMA for $5,200. What are their options under The Road Home housing
plan?
Homeowner Summary
Pre-storm Value: $110,000
Loss to Home: $110,000 x 30% = $33,000
Insurance: $0
FEMA Assistance: $5,200
44
Cost to elevate home to meet FEMA standards: $35,000
Repair or Rebuild
Eligible Road Home Grant Award = ($33,000 - $5,200) x 70% = $19,460
Note that a 30% penalty applies to those who failed to purchase insurance for their homes.
Penalty applies to those without flood insurance in a designated flood plane and those without
hazard insurance that were outside the flood plane.
Hazard mitigation grant = $35,000
Summary of Costs / Losses Summary of benefits
Damage to Home:
Additional Mitigation Costs:
Total
$33,000
$35,000
$68,000
FEMA:
Road Home:
Mitigation:
Total
$5,200
$19,460
$35,000
$59,660
In this case, there remains an uncompensated gap of $8,340 due to the homeowner's lack of
insurance. The loan program is available to provide capital to fill this gap plus additional repair
costs beyond the amount of loss.
Relocate/Buyout
If you want to sell the rights to your home and move somewhere else in Louisiana, the state will
pay you up to the amount of your damages, based on the pre-storm value of your home. You also
may be eligible for an affordable loan to cover the gap if there is a difference between repair
costs and the grant you receive. The grant and loan amounts would be the same as under the
"repair/rebuild" model.
Eligible Road Home Grant Award = ($33,000 - $5,200) x 70% = $19,460
Summary of Costs / Losses Summary of benefits
Damage to Home:
$33,000
FEMA:
Road Home:
Total
$5,200
$19,460
$24,660
If required, hazard mitigation funds will be available at the new location. Total Road Home
assistance, including hazard mitigation funds and loan, cannot exceed $150,000. Generally, for a
person with only 30% damage, the relocate option is much less attractive than the repair
program.
Sell
If they wish to move somewhere outside of Louisiana, the state will buy their home for 60
percent of its pre-storm value or the amount of eligible assistance under the repair/rebuild
program, whichever is less.
45
Seller would receive lesser of:
Pre-storm Value: $110,000 X 60% = $66,000
OR
Eligible Road Home Grant under Repair/Rebuild : $19,460
Summary of Costs / Losses Summary of benefits
Pre-storm value of home
sold:
$110,000
FEMA:
Road Home:
Total
$5,200
$19,460
$24,660
In this case, the seller who relocates out of state is out the difference of $110,000 - $24,660 =
$85,340. The sell program is especially unfavorable to those with only limited damage (in this
case 30%). It is unlikely that anyone that has less than severe damage will take this option. The
LRA acknowledges that the sell option is generally the least favorable; however, the goal of the
Road Home program is to encourage our citizens to revitalize our communities here in
Louisiana. The seller could use the assignability option and use the repair/rebuild program to
return the property to its original condition, and then sell the property on the open market to a
new resident homeowner that will agree to the covenants of the program.
Case 3 - Insured family of four
A two-income family of four with a home with a pre-storm value of $250,000 had a damage loss
of 70%. They received an insurance payment of $150,000 and received a check from FEMA for
$5,200. What are their options under The Road Home housing plan?
Homeowner Summary
Pre-storm Value: $250,000
Loss to Home: $250,000 x 70% = $175,000
Insurance: $150,000
FEMA Assistance: $5,200
Cost to elevate home to meet FEMA standards: $40,000
Repair or Rebuild
Eligible Road Home Grant Award = $175,000 - $150,000 - $5,200 = $19,800
Hazard mitigation grant = $40,000
Summary of Costs / Losses Summary of benefits
Damage to Home:
Additional Mitigation Costs:
Total
$175,000
$40,000
$215,000
Insurance:
FEMA:
Road Home:
Mitigation:
Total
$150,000
$5,200
$19,800
$40,000
$215,000
Note: Homeowners may be eligible for an affordable loan to cover the gap if there is a difference
between repair costs and the grant they receive.
Relocate/Buyout
46
If you want to sell the rights to your home and move somewhere else in Louisiana, the state will
pay you up to the amount of your damages, based on the pre-storm value of your home. You also
may be eligible for an affordable loan to cover the gap if there is a difference between repair
costs and the grant you receive. The grant and loan amounts would be the same as under the
"repair/rebuild" model.
Eligible Road Home Grant Award = $175,000 - $150,000 - $5,200 = $19,800
Summary of Costs / Losses Summary of benefits
Damage to Home:
$175,000
Insurance:
FEMA:
Road Home:
Total
$150,000
$5,200
$19,800
$175,000
If required, hazard mitigation funds will be available at the new location. Total Road Home
assistance, including hazard mitigation funds and loan, cannot exceed $150,000.
Sell
If they wish to move somewhere outside of Louisiana, the state will buy their home for 60
percent of its pre-storm value or the amount of eligible assistance under the repair/rebuild
program,, whichever is less.
Seller would receive lesser of:
Pre-storm Value: $250,000 X 60% = $150,000
OR
Eligible Road Home Grant under Repair/Rebuild : $19,800
Summary of Costs / Losses Summary of benefits
Pre-storm value of home
sold:
$250,000
Insurance:
FEMA:
Road Home:
Total
$150,000
$5,200
$19,800
$175,000
In this case, the seller who relocates out of state is out the difference of $250,000 - $175,000
= $75,000. The LRA acknowledges that the sell option is generally the least favorable; however,
the goal of the Road Home program is to encourage our citizens to revitalize our communities
here in Louisiana. The seller could use the assignability option and use the repair/rebuild
program to return the property to its original condition, and then sell the property on the open
market to a new resident homeowner that will agree to the covenants of the program.
47
APPENDIX 3
ELIGIBLE ACTIVITIES AND NATIONAL OBJECTIVES
The funds used to support activities in this Action Plan are CDBG eligible activities and
will meet one of the three CDBG National Objectives. The Eligible Activities and
National Objectives are:
Eligible Activities Regulatory Citation Statute 42USC5305
Acquisition 570.201(a) Section 105(a) (1)
Homeowner
compensation and
incentives
Pending waiver Pending waiver
New construction Pending waiver Pending waiver
Housing Advisory services
to property owners
570.201(k) Section 105(20)
Rehabilitation 570.202 Section 104(d)
Reconstruction P.l. 104-234
amendments to
Section 105(a)(4) of
42USC5305
Code enforcement 570.202(c) Section 105(a) (3)
Planning, Administration,
and Technical Assistance
570.205 and 570.206 and
570.201(p)
Section 105(12),
105(13), 105(19)
National Objectives
Activities benefiting L/M
persons
570.483 (b)
Activities which aid in the
prevention or elimination
of blight
570.483 (c)
Activities that meet
particular urgency
570.483 (d)